Eye tracking Proves David Ogilvy’s Work (Still) Rocks

Share

David Ogilvy, one of the most influential men in advertising died 10 years ago today. To commemorate this day we are proud to share some recent eye tracking research that prove his classic magazine advertisement layout (still) out performs contemporary designs.

We compared three ‘contemporary’ luxury car advertisements:

Those familiar with David Ogilvy’s work will immediately recognise that the Porsche advert is based on the classic David Ogilvy layout, like the Rolls Royce advert below:

The advertisements were placed into a magazine and shown to 60 male consumers from groups A, B and C1 aged between 30 and 55.

As you can see from the heatmaps all the salient features of the Porsche advert were noted, the car, key message, call to action and logo:

Porsche 911 with heat map showing eye tracking results

Porsche 911 with heat map showing eye tracking results

Digging into the detailed findings reveals that the Porsche advert significantly out-performed BMW and Mercedes in two key areas; noting the call to action and the logo.

Ad

Noted call to action

Noted brand

Porsche 59% 63%
Mercedes 29% 20%
BMW 11% 8%

The findings are particularly impressive when you note that the Porsche advertisement is a single page and the Mercedes and BMW are double page spreads.

  • Pingback: Twitted by thelonioushawke

  • http://www.Cognation.net dean collins

    I’m not a website consultant.

    I’m not even a website developer.

    But I’m calling BS on that porsche advertisement theory above.

    Even i know that eye tracking analysis is only relevant when you are comparing people looking at one of two or more elements.

    Basically in the porsche example above you only have two elements and white space….. what did you think people were going to be spending time looking at white space elements?

    Time to go back to the drawing board before you start billing clients for that research.

    Or am i missing something?

    Would be happy to read a reply here that explains what you think i’m missing.

    Cheers,
    Dean

  • Pingback: Twitted by bergbrandt

  • http://kiel.tumblr.com Matthew Delprado

    @ dean collins

    I think you missed the point. The fact that it is that simple IS what makes it work.

    There is an image, a logo, a headline and body copy, but the layout makes it incredibly clear.

    Or am I missing your argument?

    I would have loved to have seen the heatmaps for the other two ads.

  • http://www.thinkeyetracking.com Lizzie Maughan

    Rory Sutherland of Ogilvy makes some interesting points about this matter in his campaign blog this week: http://community.brandrepublic.com/blogs/rory_sutherlands_blog/default.aspx

  • Pingback: Tests Indicate Ogilvy’s Old-School Layout Still a Winner | FutureNow's GrokDotCom / Marketing Optimization Blog

  • Pingback: In Praise of Long Copy | Benjablog

  • DaveB

    Looking at the actual heatmap for the porsche ad, I somehow doubt that 63% of the test subjects noted the brand. Based on the published numbers, the number of people taking note of the brand outpaced those who noted the call to action, a conclusion which a simple glance at the heatmap simply does not support.

    I’m also skeptical about the fact that you did not release actual heatmaps for the other two ads used in this evaluation.

  • Karl K

    Thank you Lizzie, was unaware of Rory’s blog. Lot to learn from that man.

  • Pingback: Ogilvy’s Layouts: Why they still work « TESTBrain Dump Marketing

  • http://GuadalupeEckler Rocky Kohner

    It’s awesome to see that the newer bloggers are once more aiming at providing a more rounded info instead of just concentrating on worthless and garbagy articles. Like this the strengths of individual article are more feasable to be uncovered.

  • http://svn.durchmesser.ch/trac/bindagentx/ticket/155 Tristan Charters

    You made some good points on this topic.

  • http://watchsherlockholmesonlinefree.wetpaint.com Eneida Kloeck

    Fantastic post, I will be sure to save this in my Diigo account. Have a awesome evening.

  • http://www.marketingmaximum.com/ourservices/guaranteedseo Guaranteed seo

    Useful post, like it

  • http://www.zencarttemplates.net Young Landrith

    Superb website, I seldomly find weblogs that I follow these days, articles like yours remind me of the fact that my browser has bookmarks! :D

  • http://www.zencarttemplates.net Shalanda Bures

    Who said weblogs are dead? Sites like yours are the reason why people still read web-logs:D

  • http://twindowncomfortershop.com Asa Evans

    When are you heading to post again? You extremely inform lots of people!